UMC’s spat with Dallas megachurch ‘a really important church/state issue’
DALLAS (BP) – Religious liberty and the waning influence of Christian denominations in America are at the heart of a Dallas megachurch’s dispute with the United Methodist Church (UMC), Methodist theologians say.
Highland Park Methodist Church voted late last month by a 90 percent majority to leave the UMC. But unlike the 7,600 conservative-leaning congregations that left over LGBTQ issues from 2019-23, Highland Park’s debate with America’s largest Methodist denomination is over governance.
“The key issue is that this megachurch no longer finds it useful to be attached to its denomination,” said Mark Tooley, president of the Institute on Religion and Democracy and an advocate of United Methodist renewal. “It finds its denomination to be seemingly irrelevant to its ministries, so that’s revealing of overall trends in American Christianity, which is increasingly post-denominational.”
Highland Park contends the denomination cannot control its property or finances. The UMC says otherwise, and it asserted that claim in a lawsuit against Highland Park.
Highland Park’s 15,000-member congregation meets adjacent to the campus of Southern Methodist University (SMU) and includes former president George W. Bush among its members. Bush made news when a spokesman said he and his wife Laura participated in the vote over leaving the UMC. Bush’s chief of staff told The Dallas Morning News the former president and first lady are “grateful” to Highland Park’s pastor “for so faithfully guiding the congregation through these rough waters.”
The conflict germinated in 2022, when Highland Park changed its governing documents to grant the congregation sole authority over its ministry, oversight and denominational affiliation. The UMC’s regional governing body, the Horizon Texas Conference, says it learned of the changes in 2025. The conference’s lawsuit, filed earlier this year in Texas state court, claims Highland Park’s governing document amendments violated the congregation’s original governing documents as well as denominational policy.



