Review: "Shepherds for Sale," by Megan Basham
By Samuel D. James - Posted at Digital Liturgies:
The title expresses this: Shepherds for Sale. What the book wants to be is a devastating exposure of evangelical corruption and fraud. But there are too many factual errors, logical inconsistencies, unwarranted assumptions, and bad-faith interpretations for it to be that. Its usefulness is buried underneath a basic failure to be worthy of its own title.We ought not judge a book by its cover. Judging a book by its title, however, is a little different. A book’s title matters for more than grabbing the would-be reader’s attention or flashing a bit of memorable literary style. A book’s title tells you what the author is really saying. When the illustrations get fuzzy or the line of argument hard to follow, a good title can help you understand.
Megan Basham’s new book has a splendid title. Shepherds for Sale: How Evangelical Leaders Traded the Truth for a Leftist Agenda is clear, energetic, and memorable. It evokes intrigue, shock, disgust, and outrage. It suggests betrayal and treason. It promises not just a sermon, but an indictment.
This is the kind of book that will generate much discussion even among people who haven’t read it. Basham, a veteran reporter of World Magazine now with The Daily Wire, has offered a far-reaching diagnosis of American conservative evangelicalism.
See also:
- Megan Basham's Shepherds For Sale: The Problems With This Book (youtube.com)
- Responding to Megan Basham's Latest Claims (youtube.com)
- “Shepherds For Sale” by Megan Basham – Old News? My Review – The Reformed Reader Blog (wordpress.com)
- “Shepherds for Sale” and Immigration Views: A Mixing of Categories – The Reformed Reader Blog (wordpress.com)
- In Defense of Gavin Ortlund – Jonathan's Headspace (jonathansheadspace.blog)
- Which Shepherds Are For Sale? - Warren Cole Smith - The Dispatch
- We Can't Come Down (mereorthodoxy.com)
- Shepherds, Basham and the Truth about Those ERLC Donations (janetmefferd.com)
- The Basham Believers: No Evidence? No Ethics? No Problem! (janetmefferd.com)
- Basham Criticized for Naming Johnny Hunt’s Sexual Abuse Accuser in New Book – MinistryWatch
Comments
Post a Comment
Welcome! Please feel free to comment, but anti-Christian comments or profanity will not be tolerated. Thank you, ed.